Friday, October 9th, 2009

Council discusses subdivision goofs; possible taxpayer costs

By William Kincaid
Two Celina subdivision developers did not follow city standards when installing their roads.
And somebody, possibly city taxpayers, must pick up the costs of any future fix-it work.
City council members at a streets and alleys committee meeting Thursday learned recent test results confirmed previous suspicions that the roads in the Reserve Subdivision, developed by Chuck Samples, and Eaglebrooke Subdivision, developed by Randy Bruns, were not installed to city standards.
The average thickness of the asphalt depth - according to city mandates - is supposed to be a minimum of 3 inches, while the thickness of the subbase depth is supposed to be a minimum of 8 inches thick.
According to test results, Reserve Subdivision roads have an average asphalt thickness of 1.3 inches and an average subbase thickness of 8.7 inches. Eaglebrooke Subdivision roads have an average asphalt thickness of 2.3 inches and an average subbase thickness of 5.3 inches - all below city standards.
"It's very disappointing," said Councilwoman Angie King, who has led a charge for better inspection procedures the last several years.
City Engineering Assistant Jeremy Hinton said the developers have pledged to add an inch of asphalt before coating the roads when more lots are sold.
"That's a Band-Aid," Councilman June Scott said, a sentiment echoed by other council members.
The asphalt coring test were conducted by CTL Engineering, Wapakoneta, for $1,100 - paid for by the city.
CTL wrote that approximately 40 percent of the pavement area in the Reserve Subdivision and 70 percent of the pavement in Eaglebrooke Subdivision will require remediation prior to the placement of a topcoat.
"In summary, the asphalt conditions observed in both subdivisions ranged from good to failing," the report summary states. "The asphalt base course was extremely thin and severely cracked in many areas, especially at the intersections."
Many of the roads need work, including the deepening of the base and removal of existing asphalt, Celina Public Works Superintendent Joe Wolfe said.
King said two questions arise from the test: How does the city resolve the road problems and how were they allowed to happen in the first place?
Council members Myron Buxton and Scott said they think the city is ultimately responsible for paying for the remediation, as it is supposed to inspect roads.
But King strongly disagreed, pointing out the developers knew the required city standards before starting.
"What does our legal counsel say?" she asked, to which Hinton replied that he hasn't asked them yet.
Scott said he wanted to know whose responsibility it was to inspect the roads, to which no clear answer was given.
The roads in those subdivisions were never completely finished with a top coat because lots were still being sold, councilors learned. Councilman Mike Sovinski pointed out the city never officially approved any of those subdivision roads in any form because the final asphalt coat was never applied.
"It falls back on the developer and the people in the subdivision," Sovinski said about financial responsibility.
Many times roads initially can receive approval with a wheel test - which determines the compaction of the stone - but later can be found to be deficient, Sovinski said.
"There's always been a lack of documentation," he said.
Hinton said he would contact the city's legal counsel and also get a cost estimate for the required work before coming back to council.
Mayor Sharon LaRue said there is no money available this year to begin any of this work.
Also, Councilman Jeff Larmore said in the future, the city should require all subdivision developers to complete all roads in one phase, regardless of how many lots they've sold.
Additional online stories on this date
Watkins man Urban Grevenkamp's been making customer house calls for nearly 50 years
Urban Grevenkamp spends nearly every afternoon ringing doorbells and peddling household goods in a fashion rarely seen these days.
The embroidered [More]
COLDWATER - The annual Gene Weber Lions Cross Country Invitational, due to its timing and location, is usually a good indicator of how the Midwest Athletic Conference, held a week later on the Coldwater course, could shape up. [More]
Subscriber and paid stories on this date
Grand Lake Watershed
The county's economic development director and a local consultant are applying for a $100,000 grant to create a program for orderly growth and land use changes that could help improve local water quality.
Mercer County Soil and Water Conservation District (SWCD) board members took no action following an hour executive session to discuss the employment of district staff.
FORT RECOVERY - Village council members this week authorized the sale of two village-owned lots that are of no use to the village anymore, Village Administrator Randy Diller said.
A Celina alley running east and west between West Wayne and West Anthony streets - a former parking lot of Mersman Brothers' Furniture - may be vacated by city council members.
Noelle Schmitt was proud as punch to show me the blue pumpkins that her family grew this year.
"I think they're just really cool looking," Schmitt smiled as she positioned one of the pumpkins on the solitary plant for viewing.
District Golf Roundup
Compiled by Gary R. Rasberry
The Minster boys golf team qualified for the Division III state tournament next week after finishing second at the district tournament held at Stone Ridge in Bowling Green on Thursday.
COLDWATER - The game of volleyball is a rather simple game: get the ball to your best players so they can apply their talents, play great defense and make the routine plays.
MARIA STEIN - Heavy hitting at the net typically gets the most attention at volleyball matches, but a stingy defense can be just as lethal.
The Mar
Dirt late model driver Chad Ruhlman describes his relationship with his older brother Brian as more of a father-son relationship than the typical brotherly bond.
Compiled by Ryan Hines and
Gary R. Rasberry
Celina and St. Marys each qualified a doubles team to the Division II district tournament after first-round play of the sectional in Lima on Thursday.