The Little Elf Bakery is located at 118 S. Main St., Celina, on the second floor.
CELINA - Main Street's newest bakery, The Little Elf, has perfected its menu with a pinch of magic and a dash of whimsy.
Mother-and-daughter duo Tonya and Emma Fledderjohann co-own the bakery, which opened its storefront Oct. 4, though the business officially started in November of last year.
Located at 118 S. Main St., on the second floor, the bakery, which is open the first Sunday of each month, specializes in cookies, cake pops and cakes. The business also "pops up" with baked treats at selected special events around the Celina area.
When they travel together, Tonya and Emma like stopping into local bakeries to sample various delicacies but also to be transported into another world just for a minute.
Tonya and Emma Fledderjohann co-own The Little Elf Bakery in Celina.
"When we travel places, one of the first things we like to do is to see all the bakeries we can in town," Tonya said, adding that they enjoy seeing "the creativity that was involved in all the different types of pastries or baked goods."
Tonya, who has never baked before but who had a desire to learn, and Emma, who worked as a cookie decorator at a since-closed bake shop, teamed up after Barbara Lockwood closed Cakes by Design in Celina.
"Together, it worked out that I enjoy the baking and creating of the flavors and she likes to decorate," Tonya said. "I'm a really creative person…so that was more, I think, what got me into the possibility of baking - is to be able to create different flavors, the toppings. When Barb went out of business, we were already practicing even a year before that and then (when) she had to go out of business, we were like, 'Wow, maybe we should continue.'"
"I wouldn't have even thought of doing anything bakery-wise until Barb," Emma said. "When she told me she was closing, she really pushed and wanted me to start something."
Tonya owns Upstage Downtown Dance Theatre, located at the same address, and was inspired to turn a storage room into a sweet space with nods to woodland spirits, folklore and whimsical fantasy. The duo decorated the space with colorful floral arrangements, an abundance of greenery and thrifted frames. Accented with warm lighting and sweet smells, Tonya even filled some spots of the wood flooring with glitter glue and built miniature homes reminiscent of fairy houses.
The Little Elf Bakery in Celina combines whimsy with tasty treats.
"I just want them to look forward to coming to a space, whether they're coming to see us at an event or coming up here," she said. "It's just an experience, I guess. I really love creating experiences."
After toying with the idea, Tonya said she would ask Emma that if they hypothetically started a bakery, what would the name be?
"I kept saying, 'What if? What if we had a little bakery or something? What would we call it?'" she said. "We moved around with a lot of different titles and ideas and then we just kind of landed on "elf" because her (daughter's) initials are E.L.F. - Emma Lee Fledderjohann. It just made sense to call it the Little Elf Bakery."
Frosted sugar cookie perfect for the holiday season from The Little Elf Bakery in Celina.
Tonya said she enjoys large, soft cookies and wanted to learn how to make them. With a range of eight to 16 flavors, the cookie menu at Little Elf Bakery can include triple chocolate sea salt, sweet honey cornbread, maple bacon, peanut butter and cinnamon roll, though the duo likes creating event-exclusive flavors.
"I like to be able to go to a certain place knowing I'm going to get that flavor or that specific food item," Tonya said. "We do have a couple of those cookies or flavors that we offer at every event that we're at, but I love kind of surprising and actually coming up with different flavors at every place."
Tonya took numerous online classes ranging from the science of baking to food laws. For example, because the business is classified as a "cottage food production operation," it is exempt from being licensed and inspected for the production of cottage foods, according to the Ohio Department of Agriculture. The products have to be shelf-stable.
Labeling the products is also tedious because the label must be a certain font size, must include the product's weight in ounces and grams and other requirements.
The processes and laws have been a learning curve.
"Probably if someone told me I'd have to do all this at the beginning, I (would have) said, 'Okay, never mind,'" Tonya joked. "But then you learn as you go. You (have) come this far, you might as well just get it done. I'm sure there's still a lot of learning that we need to do, but we do pride ourselves on making sure everything is correct in that manner."
French vanilla cake slices from The Little Elf Bakery in Celina.
"I think the best part of this journey is that we get to combine two things we love, which is baking and creating experiences for people," Tonya continued. "We definitely want the taste to be there, but we also want everything to be something that they don't forget. I think whether someone is coming upstairs to visit the Little Elf or maybe they see us at markets or they're gonna try our new cookie flavor, we just want it to feel special. I think the most important thing is community. We're doing this for people in our community. We can do this all we want at home, but it's not going to be the same if we don't get to share it. We just want people to enjoy what we're offering."
Emma agreed, adding that she is excited to share the space with the public.
"She goes so big on details," she said of her mother. "Taking hours to do those things, she really puts a lot of work into this, and I hope people notice it."
For more information, visit the bakery's Facebook page. The bakery will be at the farmers market 9 a.m.-noon Saturday in Celina. They will also be open during Midnight Gladness, set for Dec. 4 in downtown Celina.