Friday, January 11th, 2013

Appraisers debate value loss

By Nancy Allen
Photo by Mark Pummell/The Daily Standard

Appraiser Richard Vannatta testifies Wednesday during a jury trial in Mercer County Common Pleas Court. The trial is to determine how much money the state must compensate a rural Celina couple for damage on their farmland caused by increased flooding from the West Bank spillway on Grand Lake.

A Celina couple and the state disagree on how to calculate how much the state owes them for their flood-damaged land.
Wayne and Janet Doner are among 86 landowners who won a 2011 case in the Ohio Supreme Court that blamed Grand Lake's West Bank spillway, opened in 1997, for causing increased flooding on their farmland. The court's ruling cleared the way for 52 jury trials to determine compensation for landowners.
The Doners have 263 tillable acres of farmland off the north side of Doner Road at Linn Road near the confluence of Beaver Creek and the Wabash River. About 222 of those acres flood. The flooded acres will be recorded as a permanent flowage easement of the state after the trial.
Appraiser Richard Vannatta told jury members in Mercer County Common Pleas Court on Thursday that the state owes the Doners a one-time payment of $2.4 million.
Vannatta, of Columbus, said he determined the payment amount by subtracting the value of the Doner land after the spillway was installed from the value before. He estimated the value of the land has decreased by 90 percent since the spillway opened.
When Vannatta was pressed by the state's attorney Pete DeMarco during cross examination on whether he could produce any objective, unbiased data that would support that 90 percent reduction, Vannatta replied there wasn't any.
        "I point to my experience and the fact that the damage is going to continue into infinity," said Vannatta, an appraiser for 40 years. "It's based on my judgement and experience."
        Vannatta said he also based the reduced value on cumulative negative effects the flooding has had on the land the last 15 years and the negative effect that recording the permanent flowage easement will have on the land's future value. He said he did not view sale prices for any land that floods to compare to the Doner land.
Appraiser Tom Horner, the state's expert witness, testified that the state only owes the couple $1.36 million.
Horner, of Dublin, said he too determined the payment by subtracting the value of the land after the spillway was installed from the prior value. He told jurors his estimate came from viewing sale amounts for similar properties in Mercer County that flood. He estimates the land's value has been reduced by 55 percent.
Doner's attorney Bruce Ingram asked Horner why he discounted sale prices for flood-prone farmland in the county that sold for much higher prices than the ones he used. Horner said those properties were not comparable because the soils were different from the Doners' and they were located in the livestock-heavy part of the county further south. Farmland in those areas bring higher prices than land near the Doners' which is used mostly for crops, Horner said.
During Wednesday's testimony, the Doners said before the new spillway was built their land flooded one in four years. Their land now floods almost every year, and the flooding is more severe and lasts longer. In 2011 it flooded five times, they said.
Horner agreed the footprint of the previous floodplain on the Doner land is now larger since the spillway opened.
The Doners also testified since the new spillway opened there are many areas on the river bank that have blown out, washing sand, rocks, coolers, traffic signs and other debris onto their farmland. Some of the areas were reinforced with cement only to be washed away again by floodwaters. They have broken farm equipment after hitting debris on their land, they said.
Numerous farm drainage tiles also have broken due to increased water pressure and being clogged with debris, the Doners said. There are about 30 acres they can no longer farm because of the flood damage and blown out areas, the Doners said.
The Doners' case is the first compensation trial to be held among all of the landowners involved in the lawsuit.
The state in 2012 withdrew a blanket settlement offer of $24 million when presented with a counteroffer of about $27 million, which included an additional $3 million for a few business owners and homeowners without farms involved in the case.
The trial is expected to wrap up today with closing arguments and jury deliberation. After the trial and the permanent 222-acre permanent flowage easement is recorded, the Doners will still own and be able to farm the land, and the state will legally be allowed to flood it.
Additional online stories on this date
CELINA - This year's county fair is shaping up to be a barnyard-stomper with two country music concerts and a host of new activities.
Sony Nashvill [More]
COLDWATER - The first few minutes of the second half provided Coldwater's girls basketball team some momentum and the Cavaliers knocked off New Bremen 41-34 on Thursday night at The Palace. [More]
Subscriber and paid stories on this date
CELINA - The county's general fund budget this year is $9.6 million - 6.8 percent more than in 2012 but 5.3 percent less than in 2008, the start of America's recession.
ST. MARYS - School and city officials are addressing travel safety in an effort to encourage a more healthy lifestyle by walking and bicycling to school.
Coldwater school board officers selected for year
COLDWATER - School board members on Wednesday night held an unplanned discussion on student safety.
Board member Todd Bills, who asked that the topic be added to the agenda, said a school should protect its campuses like a workplace.
Chickasaw
CHICKASAW - The Chickasaw Community Mutual Fire Company will receive $42,005 in federal funds earmarked for the purchase of extrication equipment.
WAPAKONETA - A project to clean up the Auglaize River is set to begin in March after about 10 years of planning.
The $250,000 Auglaize River Enhanc
After receiving some information about curious looking radishes growing in a Mercer County farm field last month, I made a point to check out these strange plants.
Horstman makes big plays down the stretch for New Knoxville
NEW KNOXVILLE - The last time the Marion Local Flyers and New Knoxville Rangers locked horns, the game came down to one big shot at the end.
On Thursday night at The Barn, both teams hit big shots near the end of the game but the end result was the same as last year's outcome.
CELINA - The Celina girls basketball team has shown an ability to beat their opponents in a number of different ways during their recent run of dominance.
Local Roundup
Compiled by Gary R. Rasberry
Fort Recovery's girls basketball team pulled away from Parkway during the second half to stay unbeaten in Midwest Athletic Conference play after a 56-35 triumph over the Panthers on Thursday.
MINSTER - Powered by a suffocating defense, Minster's girls basketball team rolled to a 31-20 win over Delphos St. John's on Thursday night in Midwest Athletic Conference action.